About us  |  Our People  |  What We do  |  Events  |  E-newsletter  |  Our communication  |  Resources  |  Contribute  |  Contact Us
WHAT'S NEW!
E-newsletter Aug-Sep'08: Internet cos. invite
  Click here

Panel Discussion: 'Who will save the girl
  Click here

E-newsletter June-July'08: Laadli promotes
  Click here

  May 2004
You are here: Home E-newsletter May 2004
Document Actions

May 2004

by edward last modified 17-08-07 22:14
:: 1 May 2004-Newsletter :: From: Population First
Sent: Thursday, April 29, 2004 1:06 PM
To: mattard_kini@vsnl.net
Subject: Newsletter-May 2004



A Communications Initiative for Sustainable Human Development in India

E-NEWSLETTER Inaugural Issue » 1 May 2004




ADVANI PROMOTES TWO CHILD NORM Will The Ruling Alliance Go Back On The Rights Approach To Population?
India s Deputy Prime Minister Mr. Lal Krishna Advani has on two occasions during the current election campaign spoken for strictly imposing a two child norm. There is a need for a blend of incentives and disincentives so that all Indian families in future abide by the two-child norm. I repeat my earlier suggestion of debarring those who violate the two-child norm from holding public office, Mr.. Advani said on April 11, 2004 at Janjgir in Chhattisgarh State. [Full statement at http://www.bjp.org/Press/april_1104a.htm]. Earlier, on March 18, 2004 at Jagityal in Andhra Pradesh State, the Deputy Prime Minister called for similar State action against families who have more than two children [see box for news story as filed by Press Trust of! India].
There is no doubt that the two child norm needs to be promoted in India if the country wishes to stabilise its population by 2045 as set out in the National Population Policy 2000.

But the big issue is how we go about this. Indeed, the route to this is set out in the NPP document itself, which was issued by the government of which Mr.Advani is such a senior member. NPP clearly lays down that the two child norm should be pursued within the framework of social development. By focusing on the need to provide quality and gender-sensitive health services, improving female literacy and working for women s empowerment, the NPP set out an enlightened framework within which population goals need to be reached.

So much so, that the NPP document has been hailed as a first big step in the country s effort to look at population issues from the perspective of social development, and is the reference point for India s current rights based approach to the subject.

It is against this backdrop that Mr.Advani s statements come as disturbing backtrack to a quick fix model that has failed time and again.

It is today an accepted position among demographers, policy watchers and government sources that population growth is higher among the most disadvantaged sections like the rural poor, migrant slum populations, and the tribals. Unchecked population growth, thus, relates directly to poverty and lack of access to health and education facilities.
Jagityal (Andhra Pradesh), Mar 18 (PTI) Deputy Prime Minister L K Advani today sought political consensus on strict implementation of two child norm in the country and a one-time amendment to pave way for a fixed five year term and simultaneous elections for Lok Sabha and state assemblies.
"I strongly advocate a policy whereby all individuals who violate the two-child norm will be automatically debarred from holding public office and government job. I believe this will be strong disincentive for large families," he told a press conference in this naxal-infested town in Telengana region on the ninth day of his Bharat Udhay Yatra.

Disagreeing with a questioner that his proposal on two child norm might go against minorities, Advani said "This should not be construed as anti-minority policy".

The Deputy Prime Minister, however, said there should be a political consensus on the issue. "Efforts will be made to build this consensus after the elections are over. It had to be done in a manner that is acceptable to all". PTI

>>>Source: Press Trust of India >>>
It is these vulnerable sections of society that will need government support by means of health services, primary education and the like. Till these don t reach them, they will be caught in the vicious circle of poverty leading to higher mortality and so larger families. [The Basics] By keeping them from holding any public office and from the government job market, the government can only ensure that the marginalised, particularly women, are further denied access to development resources.

In fact, Mr.Advani s statement itself shows that development is the best contraceptive. As he said at Jagtial [Andhra Pradesh]: It is not a question of majority and minority. If it is an educated family, it would adopt two-child norm irrespective of its religious belief. Facts and figures apart, what could be a better illustration of population being an issue of development rather than the subject matter of targets. If educated families go for a two child norm, then Mr.Advani ought to advocate educating the country, not using the threat of disincentives or the lure of incentives to reach goals.

However, we do agree that there is a need to bridge the demographic gap between the southern states and the northern states. The government will do well to focus on the three issues which are important, apart from social development, for achieving replacement level fertility in high fertility states and districts of the country  making services accessible to those with contraceptive needs (meeting the unmet need), countering the marked preference for a male child and promoting spacing in a big way.

It is also important to ask ourselves how justifiable is it for a nation whose constitution promises protection against discrimination to make parity i.e. whether one is a first, second or a third child, the basis for discrimination. Since Mr.Advani said he would look for political consensus on the two child norm, it is time the various stake holders take a position on the issue. By doing so, we at least ensure that any policy decision at a later stage would be based on a healthy understanding of the issues.
Your Response
MANIFESTO
The demographic transition India is witnessing calls for structural changes that can no longer be avoided in the policy making process. As India s top political parties head for the polls to form a new national government, Population First sought to build political consensus on health and population issues. In this regard, a consultative meeting was held on 24 January to identify the framework to be adopted by the political parties in their manifestoes. The intention was to detect the gap between professed intentions and actual action and to get leading political parties to commit themselves to bridge the gap with appropriate resource allocation. A draft manifesto was submitted to all the political parties. More....
MOTIVATION THROUGH EXPERIMENTAL THEATRE
The two residential five-day Motivational Workshops took place at the Thane District Training Centre in January and February 2004. The initiative was taken forward after the release of an assessment report which highlighted the problems in health communications in the two Primary Health Centres [PHCs] areas of Dolkhamb and Kinhavali in Thane district. The participants, PHC personnel, had a chance to experience themselves and each other as they were affirmatively pushed to a higher ground of self-acknowledgement by Manjul Bharadwaj, the workshop conductor. Motivation was heightened through the techniques of experimental theatre. Not intending to technically train or skill the participants, the sessions brought to the fore the potential of many health workers in planning and providing effective services. The workshop resulted in building their self-confidence and self-respect to help them perform their duties better. More....
HEALTH CAMPS ON INTERNATIONAL WOMEN'S DAY
click to view In celebration of the spirit of the women, Population First organised two separate health melavas [meaning fairs in Marathi] in the PHCs of Dolkhamb and Kinhavali.
The underlying theme of the event was Women Have a Right to Health which was emphasized by the many activities put forward. General health check-ups, child health, counselling services and games were held in a non-threatening and friendly atmosphere. The main objective was to provide information in an entertaining and interesting fashion using cultural activities, games and group counselling sessions. More....
TRUSTEES MEETING
The meeting was held at the Indian Merchants Chamber on 6 February 2004, bringing together for the first time the Board of Trustees and the Advisory Council of Population First. Important issues related to the organisation s activity such as the Thane pilot project, Youth Campaign and Media Advocacy were covered and discussed. One of the high moments of the meeting was the launching of the website, which is designed as the central feature in the organisation s communications strategy. Rajashree Birla, a promoter of development initiatives of the Birla Group, inaugurated the site. More....
POPULATION FIRST
Population First is a communications based initiative that embraces the government objective of achieving population stabilisation by the year 2045. Working to support the government s programmes, Population First builds the communication foundations for partnership between government, civil society, the corporate sector and the media, creating a common ground for the sharing views and perspectives that will help lead change in society. The whole idea evolves around the belief that empowering women to exercise their rights helps achieve social development and provides a refreshing and appropriate framework for addressing issues related to health and population. A focus area of the organisation is reproductive health, which is closely connected with decisions on family size and must be seen within the context of equal rights for women and children. In this endeavour, Population First counts on the responsible participation of the community, a response which we hope to kick start at least in part by our communications initiatives. More....



Shetty House, 3rd Floor, 101 MG Road, Mumbai-400021, India
Telephones: 91 22 2262 6599/6672 Fax: 91 22 2270 2217
E-mail: populationfirst@vsnl.net
Website: www.populationfirst.org
Top

Copyright 2004, Population First


SUBSCRIBE TO
OUR NEWSLETTER
 

UN-SUBSCRIBE TO
OUR NEWSLETTER
 
View Latest Newsletter Here
 
Total Hits :666
Lack of access to family planning is a major factor behind the 76 million unintended pregnancies every year in the developing world. Source: Unfpa